Blog Notes

What Makes for a Good Blog to Read?

Over the years I’ve spent a lot of time thinking about the answer to that question as I created my Best Reads of the Week series on Dyvers and my Great Blog Roll Call series. The answer, I think, comes down to three things: consistency, creativity, and provocativeness.

Consistency

Consistency isn’t just publishing on a schedule, but rather posting throughout the year. We all have busy lives – and for the vast majority of us blogging is a hobby, and not a job – so to expect someone who is doing this for fun to keep to a schedule is a bit unfair. Which is why when I say that someone is “consistent with their blog” I mean that they publish throughout the year.

This is why when I write the Great Blog Roll Call I do the blog posts as an average throughout the year. This provides the reader with a general idea of how often they should check back on the blog and it gives a general health of the blog itself. For example, we’ve made it through 239 days so far this year. If a blog has only published 1 post then it isn’t a very consistent blog. By contrast, if a blog has published 60 posts this year, or an average of a post every 4 days, then its quite healthy.

Creativity

Often when you see someone talk about creativity they’re referring to originality in thought.  That isn’t what we’re discussing here.

Creativity in blogging is about approaching a subject that others may have covered and discussing it in a way that makes it your own. For example, when Arnold K., author of Goblin Punch, wrote What Is Tested? it wasn’t the first article on dungeon design that had ever been published. It wasn’t even the first time that someone had discussed the importance of testing your players’ skill in your adventure design; but the way that Arnold went about the topic made it entirely their own and brought a lot of people into the discussion about how we design dungeons for our games.

Being creative doesn’t require that you move the needle each time that you begin writing for your blog, but it does mean that each topic you write about becomes your own – even if everyone else has already talked about it.

Provocativeness

This one is a bit controversial, but it’s an important aspect of blogging all the same. When I say that a blog needs to be provocative I’m not talk about it being controversial, though that’s often what people take from that word. What I’m discussing is the way that a blog moves a discussion.

In The Auction of the first Hundred Words author pjamesstuart, of the blog False Machine, discusses the way that we prioritize the words we use in our adventure texts and attempts to focus not only their own thoughts, but that of the reader, on the proper way to orient the text.  It’s a provocative piece that pushes the reader to rethink how they would provide the information and what information they can discard.

Posts that cause you to come back to them time, and time again are the sort of posts that I enjoy highlighting and exemplify what I mean by being provocative. They inspire your own imagination and excite you to write about the same topics.

10 thoughts on “What Makes for a Good Blog to Read?”

  1. Interesting. Perhaps you should consider revisiting your listings of Blogs you really like, adding which of the above criteria are showcased by a given Blog. One might be favored for its Consistency and Creativity while another might be Creative and Provocative which being unfortunately Inconsistent.

    I’d love to see Blogs that are noted for all three categories.

    Liked by 2 people

  2. Which reminds me…any plans to do a new “Great Blog Roll Call?” I was just reading though your last one, and I saw a few names missing that I’ve been reading lately.
    ; )

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Here are a few more:

    Chaos Magick-User (magickuser.wordpress)
    Wampus Country
    Hobby Games Reecce
    Bones of Contention
    POCGamer
    All Dead Generations AND Dungeon of Signs (GusL’s two blogs)
    Destination Unknown (unknownzine.blogspot)
    The Sword of Sorcery (hexelis.blogspot)
    Age of Ravens
    wmusswtwbf (.wordpress)
    Whose Measure God Could Not Take
    Throne of Salt
    Chiquita Fajita (was .wordpress, now .blogspot)

    Man…there are a LOT of blogs out there. Most of these are recently active. Age of Ravens and wmusswtwbf haven’t had a post since 2019, but they have great content that’s still worth reading.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.